Did Colorado’s ban on legacy admissions enhance state faculties’ variety?

Join our free month-to-month e-newsletter Past Excessive Faculty to maintain up with information about faculty and profession paths for Colorado highschool grads.  

The U.S. Supreme Court docket’s ruling prohibiting race-conscious admissions has led to calls to ban one other type of choice — legacy admissions — in pursuit of extra inclusive campuses.

In 2021, Colorado grew to become the primary state to ban legacy admissions — the method of giving an admissions edge to youngsters of alumni — at public universities. The purpose was to assist admit a extra various scholar physique.

At CU Boulder, the state’s flagship, admissions for college kids who’re the primary of their households to attend faculty elevated in 2022, however barely fewer college students of colour had been admitted.

At Mines, the state’s most selective public faculty, the college admitted extra college students of colour, about the identical variety of first-generation college students, and fewer ladies in 2022 — however the faculty accepted and enrolled a extra various class in 2023.

The traits at Mines and CU Boulder paint a fuzzy image of whether or not banning legacy admissions elsewhere would improve campus variety or present extra alternative for college kids from marginalized backgrounds.

Complicating the image: Colorado public universities modified a number of different insurance policies on the identical time, together with making check scores such because the SAT and ACT exams elective and increasing recruitment in various communities. These modifications have affected who utilized, what number of college students had been accepted, and who ended up on campus.

Admissions workplaces on the two universities stated they wish to present extra dedication to diversifying their campuses along with banning legacy admissions. They report they’re dealing with extra competitors from different colleges with decrease tuition or extra monetary support. They’re additionally battling perceptions about whether or not a campus is welcoming if there may be not as a lot variety among the many college students.

“Faculties are extra aggressive with what they’re doing,” stated Lori Kester, Mines’ affiliate provost for enrollment administration. “Folks assume the writing’s on the wall because the inhabitants dwindles. Folks in increased ed are all going after the identical college students.”

Earlier this month, the Biden administration inspired faculties and universities to evaluate their admissions insurance policies, together with ending using legacy preferences. The Workplace of Civil Rights is investigating whether or not legacy preferences represent discrimination. Democrats in Congress have additionally launched laws that may bar colleges with legacy admissions from collaborating in federal monetary support.

Most of Colorado’s public faculties and universities admit the vast majority of college students that apply. CU Boulder and Mines are extra selective.

In 2022, CU Boulder functions had been up in 2022 to about 54,000, or about 10,500 extra functions than in 2020. The college accepted about 79% of scholars who utilized that yr.

About 77% of all college students of colour had been accepted — a slight lower from 81% in 2020. On the identical time, first-generation acceptance charges elevated two factors to 73%.

At Mines, the state’s engineering faculty, general functions had been down in 2022 to about 11,360 functions, or a lower of about 1,300 functions from 2020. The college accepted about 57% of all candidates — up from 55% in 2020. 

Mines admitted 54% of scholars of colour who utilized, a rise of three.4 factors from 2020. First-generation college students had been accepted at a 40% fee, about the identical as in 2020. 

Girls candidates — who’re underrepresented in science, expertise, engineering, and math fields — had been accepted at a 65% fee in 2022, down two factors from 2020.

In 2023, the college’s admissions charges elevated amongst all college students to 59%. Acceptance charges elevated amongst college students of colour to 58%, first-generation college students to 42.5%, and ladies to 66%.

The college additionally enrolled extra college students of colour, first-generation college students, and ladies.

Admissions numbers for CU Boulder in 2023 usually are not but out there.

Extra states contemplating a ban

No main analysis exists in regards to the influence of banning legacy admissions, based on Thomas Harnisch, vice chairman for presidency relations on the State Greater Training Govt Officers Affiliation. 

A number of different state legislatures are contemplating a ban, together with New York, Massachusetts, and Connecticut, he stated. Personal faculties, nevertheless, have pushed again as a result of they see legacy admissions as a strategy to get college students with ties to the college to use, encourage donations, and construct group, Harnisch stated.

Colorado’s two premier personal faculties, Colorado Faculty and the College of Denver, nonetheless contemplate alumni relations of their admissions selections.

After CU Boulder ended legacy preferences voluntarily, each CU Boulder and Mines supported laws banning legacy preferences statewide.

However each colleges’ directors stated it’s troublesome to determine anyone change because the catalyst for whether or not a scholar applies or is admitted.

In 2021, Mines and CU Boulder backed laws to make the ACT and SAT elective in admissions. On the identical time, faculty officers stated they elevated recruitment efforts and college-readiness applications. 

In follow, neither Mines nor CU Boulder weighed legacy as the only figuring out consider admissions. Banning legacy choice despatched extra of a message to college students, stated Jennifer Ziegenfus, CU Boulder assistant vice chancellor for admissions.

Ziegenfus stated scholar notion about legacy admissions was “that the coed who doesn’t have a member of the family who went there may be already ranging from behind and so they must play catch up.”

‘Welcome as many college students as doable into our group’

The test-optional change allowed Mines to sign to college students that admissions workplaces wish to know extra about the entire scholar, not only a check, stated Jen Gagne, interim government director of admissions. She added that she needs college students to know that even after the ban on race-conscious admissions, they need to showcase who they’re in private essays.

“We wish to make it possible for college students are difficult themselves within the classroom,” Gagne stated. “However we wish to learn about you. We’re on the lookout for drawback solvers for the longer term and that requires college students from all backgrounds.”

CU Boulder has additionally began to recruit extra in rural areas and employed Spanish recruiters to higher attain college students, Ziegenfus stated.

The purpose has been to unfold the message that the state’s flagship establishment is for all college students within the state, and Spanish recruiters assist not solely college students, however households see why CU Boulder is an choice, she stated. The college has additionally had extra college students in recent times reap the benefits of Colorado’s free faculty utility days, when Colorado college students can apply to schools at no cost in October.

At Mines, leaders have needed its scholar physique to look extra just like the state’s demographics. 

Mines has positioned extra give attention to pre-college applications that put together college students for science, expertise, engineering, and math programs, together with a brand new program at Lakewood’s Alameda Worldwide Jr./Sr. Excessive, Kester stated.

The college can be working extra intently with highschool counselors to get college students early math publicity as a result of the college requires college students to have a robust background within the topic. The college additionally has pushed for various pathways to get college students to Mines, equivalent to switch choices from the state’s group faculties.

Each colleges additionally face elevated competitors from out-of-state colleges, which has triggered strain on who does and doesn’t present up on campus. That’s particularly a difficulty throughout a time when extra college students fear about the price of faculty. 

Wealthier colleges can do extra to subsidize a scholar’s schooling, Kester stated, which has triggered some to look elsewhere. Some out-of-state public colleges have decrease general tuition charges even when in comparison with Colorado’s in-state tuition or can present monetary support to offset prices.

Ziegenfus stated she hopes college students of colour know they’ve a spot regardless of the college not having the ability to contemplate race any longer. CU Boulder thought-about race in admissions. Mines didn’t.

She added admissions officers are on the lookout for methods to get them an acceptance letter.

“It’s the purpose of most establishments throughout the state to have the ability to welcome as many college students as doable into our group,” Ziegenfus stated. “No matter efforts we are able to make to knock down these limitations — perceived or in any other case — it’s at all times going to be on the root of our mission.”

Jason Gonzales is a reporter overlaying increased schooling and the Colorado legislature. Chalkbeat Colorado companions with Open Campus on increased schooling protection. Contact Jason at jgonzales@chalkbeat.org.